Canada Dry Ginger Ale: The Ultimate Beverage

Introduction

What should we choose to drink with our meals? Wine, beer, sake—these alcoholic beverages are often discussed in terms of their "pairing" with food. But is this "compatibility" truly rational?

In this article, I argue that Canada Dry Ginger Ale is the finest choice as a mealtime beverage. For those who cannot tolerate alcohol due to their constitution, or for those who drink "just for the atmosphere" without actually finding it particularly enjoyable, I would like to propose a new possibility.

The Characteristics of Canada Dry Ginger Ale

The "Dry" Design Philosophy

Canada Dry was developed in 1904 by John J. McLaughlin, a pharmacist in Toronto, Canada. Unlike the sweet, dark-colored ginger ales that dominated the market at the time, this product—named "Pale Dry"—was designed to achieve 'a crisp, less sweet taste' reminiscent of dry champagne¹.

This "not too sweet" design philosophy plays a decisive role in food pairing.

The Role of Palate Cleansing

Canada Dry excels as a mealtime beverage due to the following three functions:

Physical Cleansing Effect: Carbon dioxide gas forms bubbles on the tongue, delivering a physical scrubbing effect. It lifts and removes lipids and food residue adhering to the tongue's surface and the crevices between taste buds².

Chemical Cutting Effect: Canada Dry has a pH of approximately 2.82, which is more acidic than most wines (pH 3.0–3.6)³. This acidity has the ability to chemically "cut through" animal fats and fried oils.

The Action of Gingerol: Gingerol, the pungent compound derived from ginger, serves essentially the same function as the pickled ginger (gari) served with sushi. It acts as a neurophysiological switch that interrupts the lingering flavors of previous dishes while also promoting digestion⁴.

Comparison with Other Ginger Ales

Schweppes tends to be "mellow" with a gentler ginger flavor and more prominent sweetness⁵. Wilkinson and ginger beers can have an overly intense ginger spiciness, risking the masking of delicate culinary flavors⁶.

Canada Dry achieves a "golden mean"—moderate sweetness, sharp carbonation, and a ginger flavor that is present but not overpowering—that resets the palate without interfering with the food⁷.

Alcohol: An "Anomalous" Choice

Why Do People Drink "Unpleasant" Liquids?

Why do adults come to enjoy the bitterness and astringency that children instinctively reject? Psychologist Paul Rozin termed this phenomenon "Benign Masochism"⁸. While the body signals "danger," the brain recognizes "safety"—and the very act of overcoming this dissonance triggers the release of dopamine and endorphins, transforming the experience into pleasure.

In other words, the essence of finding alcohol "delicious" lies in the "pleasure of mastery"—the brain overpowering the body's defensive instincts. Humanity often constructs noble-sounding purposes for such self-defeating behaviors. We award ourselves the band-aid of "refined taste" as if it were a medal of honor.

Alcohol Preference as an Evolutionary Vestige

According to Robert Dudley's "Drunken Monkey Hypothesis," primates are attracted to the smell of alcohol because the fermentation odor of ripe fruit served as an olfactory beacon signaling "high-calorie food is here"⁹. Approximately 10 million years ago, a genetic mutation in alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH4) occurred in human ancestors, improving ethanol metabolism capacity by roughly 40-fold¹⁰.

Modern humans can consume alcohol simply because it was once not a "poison" but a "survival energy source"—and those who could tolerate it survived. Those who couldn't were eliminated. Our taste receptors accept alcohol not because it is "delicious," but merely because the genes that survived atop countless corpses recognize it as "calories advantageous for survival."

The Chemical Fragility of Alcohol Pairing

The phrase "wine and food marriage" is beautiful—but beauty is all it is.

The iron and tannins in red wine react with the unsaturated fatty acids in seafood, producing an intense fishy, metallic taste¹¹. Alcohol heightens the sensitivity of capsaicin receptors, causing spicy dishes to be perceived as painful when paired together¹². High alcohol content numbs the taste buds, making it impossible to appreciate delicate broths or subtle ingredient flavors¹³.

The act of pairing alcohol with food has become an embodiment of "specious beauty."

The Myth That "Medieval Water Was Dangerous"

The notion that "people in the past drank beer and wine instead of water because water was contaminated" has served as a myth justifying alcohol consumption. However, recent historical research has debunked this claim¹⁴.

Contemporary documents and medical texts contain numerous recommendations for consuming clean spring water and well water. Alcohol was consumed not primarily for sterilization purposes, but for its high caloric value as an energy source, social status, and the desire for its psychoactive effects¹⁵.

In modern developed nations, there is absolutely no necessity for alcohol as hydration. Alcohol consumption is purely a "choice" of indulgence—not a "necessity" for survival.

Alcohol Intolerance Is an "Evolved Defense Mechanism"

For individuals with low or deficient ALDH2 (aldehyde dehydrogenase 2) activity, this is not merely a "weakness" but may represent a highly evolved "defense mechanism."

It has been suggested that elevated blood acetaldehyde levels may suppress the proliferation of pathogens such as Entamoeba histolytica and Mycobacterium tuberculosis¹⁶. Furthermore, there is a correlation between regions with high hepatitis B virus prevalence and the distribution of ALDH2 deficiency—making alcohol consumption difficult may have functioned as a survival strategy that reduced the risk of death from viral hepatitis by lessening the burden on the liver¹⁷.

An alcohol-intolerant constitution is a powerful "biological defense shield" acquired through evolution.

The Versatility of Canada Dry

In contrast, Canada Dry Ginger Ale brings out the full potential of any dish.

For spicy foods, the sugar content envelops and softens the capsaicin stimulation like a membrane, while the carbonation disperses the sensation of pain¹⁸. Unlike alcohol, it does not amplify spiciness.

For fatty dishes, the strong carbonation and acidity physically and chemically remove grease. There is no side effect of leaving the mouth feeling rough or astringent, as red wine tannins do.

For delicate dishes, it functions as "liquefied gari," refreshing the palate from oily fish without generating fishy odors. The aromatic compounds in ginger also possess a masking effect that neutralizes seafood odors.

Conclusion: The Scientifically Correct Choice

In the modern age, our continued consumption of bitter, astringent alcohol is driven by ancient memories, masochistic pleasure-seeking that exploits neurological illusions, and social inertia.

Not drinking alcohol—or not finding it delicious—is not a deficiency in taste. Rather, it is "the normal function of survival instincts."

Choosing Canada Dry Ginger Ale is "the scientifically correct choice" for maximizing your dining experience.

However,

Having thoroughly criticized alcohol, it is also true that it has been consumed by countless people and has contributed to the formation of innumerable human relationships.

When we regard the creature called "human" as a 'Human' in the truest sense, I believe that fascination lies not in "scientific" or "rational" imitations, but in 'irrational reality' itself.

---

References